There's No Crying in Baseball

Double "Blind" U-Turn

 * Rob & Kelley U-Turned Gary & Will
 * Gary & Will U-Turned Rob & Kelley (No Effect)

Pit Stop

 * 1) Abbie & Ryan
 * 2) Trey & Lexi
 * 3) Jaymes & James
 * 4) James & Abba
 * 5) Josh & Brent
 * 6) Natalie & Nadiya
 * 7) Rob & Kelley
 * 8) Gary & Will
 * 9) Caitlin & Brittany (Eliminated)